In October, the FCC released the final text of its Report and Order eliminating the 39% national TV ownership cap – an Order adopted at its August Open Meeting (see our note here). Last week, the FCC’s Order was published in the Federal Register, noting the elimination of the national cap will be effective January 11, 2027.
While the headlines suggested that the FCC has abolished the cap, the FCC did so with the caveat that it will now do a case-by-case review of any proposed TV combination exceeding the 39% cap to see if that transaction is in the public interest. In these public interest showings, the FCC will weigh the transaction’s potential benefits (e.g., increased local programing and the financial ability to invest in new technologies to allow the stations to innovate and better compete against new media competitors) and its potential harms (e.g., decreased local programming, increased retransmission consent fees, and loss of jobs of communications workers). So, while there will no longer be a hard and fast cap after January 11, 2027, the Commission has not totally abandoned that 39% limit (remembering of course that 39% has never really been 39%, as UHF stations, now the majority of all television stations, are still entitled to a 50% discount, meaning that the audience in their markets is counted as only half that of VHF stations in the computation of whether they meet the 39% cap – see our articles here and here on the UHF discount).
In reviewing showings made in connection with acquisitions that exceed the audience share allowed under the 39% cap, the FCC appears to be starting from the position that the cap is no longer necessary. In the Order, the Commission recites all the competition to television that exists from other media – particularly from digital media. The Order states that any objections to proposed combinations that would exceed the current cap must provide specific showings why the transaction before the FCC would harm the public interest (e.g., by showing specific instances where the acquiring company engaged in conduct that produced negative results). Negatives that would be weighed include decreases in localism, increases in retransmission consent fees and, possibly, decreases in broadcast jobs (though the FCC seems to question whether analyzing jobs losses are part of the FCC’s public interest mandate, noting that “labor issues historically have been handled and enforced by [other] federal agencies.”).
Already, state cable and broadband associations have asked the FCC to say its decision (requests which the NAB opposed). Part of the arguments of opponents who oppose the relaxation of the rules is that the decision appears to put the burden on those objecting to a transaction. They argue that the need to provide specific information about a buyer (as opposed to more general information about industry conditions that are likely to be impacted by any broadcast consolidation) was an outcome for which the Commission had not given notice of its plans to require objectors to justify their objections with more than platitudes about how combinations are bad – but to require that the objector provide particularized evidence of how a specific transaction will be bad. One would think that a decision on how to resolve objections to applications that exceed the cap if the cap is lifted would have been an obvious outgrowth of the proceeding to look at whether the Commission should lift the cap, but these groups argue that it could not be foreseen.
Regardless of the outcome of the appeals of the national cap, the resolution of that issue sets the stage for the Commission’s resolution of its Quadrennial Review of the local ownership rules. Comments in that proceeding were finalized in January 2026, and a resolution of the proceeding has been expected for months. Several ownership decisions in the recent past have been made just before the holidays (e.g., the resolution of the 2018 Quadrennial Review was released on December 28, 2023) – and it again possible that this year, too, we will see a decision before the end of the year.
But even if the decision is not out for the holidays, we have seen the FCC take actions on waivers of the local rules that may well give hints that the framework adopted in the FCC’s elimination of the national cap may provide guidance for its actions on the local rules. In the last two weeks, the FCC staff approved the acquisition by Sinclair of a third television station in both the Reno and the Flint-Saginaw-Bay City TV DMAs. In those decisions, and in other recent written decisions approving waivers of the TV ownership rules (see our note here), the FCC has looked at many of the same issues that it addressed in the decision on the national caps. It has relied on the applicant’s arguments that the markets in which they are competing include not just over-the-air TV, but all other competitors in the current media landscape. These are the same issues that we have been writing about for years in articles about the need for ownership deregulation (see, for instance, our articles here and here).
These arguments go further and discuss how greater scale in their markets is needed to be able to compete against these digital competitors owned by many of the tech giants that dominate the US economy. The waiver requests also note other traditional media competitors that will remain in the market after the acquisition, seemingly to make the application easier to grant on a waiver basis.
These arguments have been convincing to Commission staff, leading to these waiver grants. Similar arguments have resulted in some waivers of the local radio ownership rules. They all may well give hints that this same framework will be used when the Commission gets to reviewing its local ownership rules, hopefully very soon.
