Here are some of the regulatory developments of significance to broadcasters from the past week, with links to where you can go to find more information as to how these actions may affect your operations.
- By a 15-0 vote, the Senate Commerce Committee voted to advance to the full Senate the nomination of Danielle Thumann Severs to be the third Republican FCC Commissioner. Thumann was nominated to fill that seat by President Trump in September. She currently works as Senior Counsel to FCC Chair Brendan Carr. The 13 Democrats on the committee did not vote on Thumann’s nomination, instead boycotting the meeting because Thumann’s nomination was not paired with a Democratic nominee for one of the open Democratic seats on the Commission. There is also a fear that, should she be confirmed, with the three Republican Commissioners constituting a quorum, the President could fire Democratic Commissioner Anna Gomez (whose term has already expired but, unless she is fired or someone else is confirmed to take her seat, she can holdover in her current position until December 31, 2027). Thumann’s nomination now proceeds to the full Senate for a vote, which Commerce Committee Chaiman Senator Cruz (R-TX) said would likely occur before the end of the year, although Democratic Senators are still pushing for that vote to be delayed and raising new issues about the nomination.
- The FCC’s Media Bureau issued an Order granting an application to assign several Delaware and Maryland radio stations to Draper Media and waiving the Local Radio Ownership Rule to allow Draper to own 9 radio stations in the Salisbury-Ocean City, MD radio market. This is 2 stations over the market cap under the current ownership rules, and the 8 FM stations it will own is 4 over the market’s FM “subcap.” A petition to deny filed against the application claimed that this ownership concentration would undermine smaller broadcasters’ ability to compete in the market. The Bureau denied the petition, stating that it failed to raise any specific issues with the application, finding instead that the application’s grant was in the public interest because it promoted localism—noting Draper’s expansion of local news and other programming offerings after prior station purchases—and gave Draper greater scale to maintain and expand local programming in the market. The Bureau also found that the greater scale gave Draper greater ability to compete both with the market’s largest radio operator and with non-broadcast audio platforms exerting significant competitive pressure on the market’s radio stations. The Bureau further found that the waiver’s grant was justified because two of the assigned stations only reached a small portion of the market’s listeners and therefore played virtually no role in competition for listeners or advertising revenue in the market.
- On our Broadcast Law Blog, we published an article discussing the FCC’s Order repealing the 39% national TV ownership cap and how the reasoning of that Order could also apply to the changes in local radio and television ownership limits being considered in the FCC’s 2022 Quadrennial Review of those rules, a decision on which is expected very soon.
- The FCC announced that December 17 is the effective date of its October Report and Order significantly revising the FCC’s procedures under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) for determining if constructing communications facilities, including broadcast towers, affect the environment. These reforms include limiting the scope of the FCC’s NEPA review, streamlining and expediting the FCC’s NEPA review process, and requiring NEPA review for broadcast activities only if a new tower needs an Antenna Structure Registration. Most of the Order’s rule changes, however, will require approval of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) before becoming effective. Thus, it appears that the only rule changes taking effect in December are the revisions clarifying which FCC actions trigger its NEPA review obligations.
- The FCC’s Enforcement Bureau issued a Notice of Illegal Pirate Radio Broadcasting to property owners in Brooklyn, New York for allegedly allowing a pirate to broadcast from their property. The Bureau warned the owners that the FCC may issue fines of up to $2,453,218 under the PIRATE Radio Act if they continue allowing the pirate to broadcast from their property.
- The Media Bureau entered into a Consent Decree with the owner of a Mississippi AM station and an FM translator to resolve its investigation after a complaint was filed alleging that the AM station was silent for over a year—which, if true, meant that the station’s license automatically expired under Section 312(g) of the Communications Act of 1934. The Bureau found that while the owner showed that the AM station was not silent for over one year (and therefore its license was not automatically forfeited under Section 312(g)), it failed to timely notify the FCC that the station was silent and to seek authority to remain silent, which is required when a station is silent for more than 30 days. The Bureau also found that the translator did not cease operations while its primary station was silent and instead originated programming, which translators cannot do as secondary services. The Consent Decree requires the station to enter into a compliance plan to ensure that future FCC rule violations do not occur.
