July 8 Filing Deadline for Commercial Broadcast Stations Form 323 Ownership Report - Clarifications Issued

The long-delayed revised Biennial ownership reports (about which we last wrote here) for commercial broadcast stations, on the new Form 323, are due on July 8, and the FCC is in the process of clarifying what it needs.  The Commission just released a Public Notice reminding broadcasters that the report is supposed to be detailing station ownership as of November 1, 2009 (when the reports were originally supposed to be filed).  Yet, in the 8 months since that date, many stations have changed ownership.  Is a new owner supposed to get the old owner to complete the form?  What if the old owner is off somewhere on a cruise, or simply wants nothing more to do with the station?  The FCC's Public Notice clarifies (to some extent) what to do in that case - indicating that stations in that situation can file a waiver request, detailing why they can't provide the ownership information for the owners who held the station license on November 1, 2009, and asking that the FCC waive its rules and excuse the filing of a report for this particular station.  This obligation to file the waiver request is on the current owner.  Note that the FCC does not say that it will grant all such waiver requests, and it specifically excludes from these waiver situations "pro forma" assignments or transfers, i.e. ones where the actual control has not changed but the legal entity holding that control has changed such as in a corporate reorganization where a station license is moved from a parent company to a subsidiary, or from a corporation to an LLC which is controlled by the same individual. 

Another looming issue may also create issues for the July 8 filings.  A group of state broadcast associations and broadcast owners has asked the US Court of Appeals to once again put the filing obligation on hold until the FCC justifies the information that is being collected.  Last week, the Court asked the Commission to justify its requirement that each person with an attributable interest in a station (i.e. anyone who would have to be reported on the Form 323) obtain an FRN (a unique identifier) which can only be obtained by furnishing a Social Security Number.  While this may indicate that the Court is concerned about forcing every investor and officer and director of a broadcast company to provide this information, even if the Court forbids the collection of that information, it is possible that the FCC would move forward anyway with the Form 323 filing obligation - just removing the FRN from the required filing.  So don't count on the July 8 deadline being pushed back - start preparing now to be on file by the deadline.

The idea behind the revised Form 323 was to give the FCC a better idea of the ownership of broadcast stations.  In particular, it was to assess the diversity of ownership - perhaps to justify more affirmative action efforts to promote ownership by minorities and women.  Without being able to identify who owns broadcast outlets, the FCC felt that it could not justify such actions.  Insisting on the uniform date of November 1 was to get a snapshot in time, that could be revisited every two years, to get a uniform set of data.  The need for the FRNs was to make sure that owners are tracked throughout all of the interests that they may have - and the Social Security Number insured that there are no errors in tracking those owners (e.g. ones that could arise from more than one person having the same name, or from the same person having different variations of his or her name being used to report interests in different companies). 

Be prepared - sooner or later the deadline is coming.  And noncommercial owners - pay attention, as your reports may be come uniform next (though, for now, noncommercial licensees continue to file on the anniversary date of the filing of license renewal applications in the state to which their station is licensed).

FCC Suspends New Form 323 Ownership Report Filing Deadline

The FCC today issued an Order suspending the upcoming January 11 deadline for the filing of new Form 323 Ownership Reports by all licensees of commercial broadcast stations.  As we have written before, the approval of this form has been a tortured process, and left open many questions about the practicalities of completing the form, as well as in connection with certain policy issues raised by the form.  Many broadcasters were, for instance, concerned about privacy issues with the provision of Social Security Numbers as is necessary to obtain a FCC Registration Number from each attributable principal as required by the new form.  Others were concerned about more practical issues that would require the entry of multiple fields of information, in some cases repeated dozens or even hundreds of times for some multiple station owners.  After receiving many protests about the burden imposed by the new form, and the short time that commercial licensees were given to prepare the report for submission (the form only becoming available earlier this month), the Commission today decided to suspend the filing deadline while it further revised the form to answer the many questions that have arisen.

So the January deadline has been lifted.  When will the re-filing take place?  It is uncertain now, as the Commission seemingly may need to make significant changes to the form to answer the many questions that have been raised (though the Order today addresses only the practical issues, not revisiting the issue of the Social Security Numbers).  The Commission did say, however, that no filing will be required for at least 90 days after the revised form is made available - hopefully giving broadcasters plenty of time to work with any revised form that is adopted to resolve any new issues that may crop up.  But for all of you who were planning on spending your holidays filling out ownership reports - you can now relax and enjoy the season's festivities!

FCC Form 323 Ownership Report Now Available for Filing

The new FCC Form 323 Ownership Report is now available in the FCC's electronic filing system.  Thus, after many delays, licensees can prepare and file the form that is due from licensees of commercial broadcast stations by January 11.  The Commission also reminded broadcasters that it will be conducting a Tutorial on the new Form on Wednesday, December 9 at 2 PM Eastern Time which can be accessed through the FCC's website

We last wrote here about the FCC's announcement of the impending availability of the form, and the decision to allow broadcasters to obtain temporary FCC Registration Numbers (FRNs) for principals from whom Social Security Numbers cannot be obtained by the January 11 filing deadline.  Thus, with the form in the database, and the Social Security Number issue temporarily resolved, broadcasters need to be preparing these forms and filing them by January 11.  The FCC has promised vigilance in enforcing this requirement - so be ready for the upcoming deadline.

New Form 323 Ownership Report Expected to be Ready This Week - And FCC Provides for Temporary FRN Without Social Security Number

The new FCC Form 323 Ownership Report is expected to be available in the FCC's CDBS electronic filing database by Wednesday, December 9, according to a Public Notice released by the FCC yesterday - so that commercial broadcasters should have a month to prepare the form in time for the January 11 filing deadline.  As we've written before, the form and filing deadline have been much delayed as the Commission struggled to work out kinks in its electronic filing process.  In the Public Notice issued yesterday, the Commission also announced that stations can file their ownership reports on the new form even if each attributable owner of the company has not yet received an FCC Registration Number (an "FRN"), which requires the provision of a Social Security Number (for individuals) or a Taxpayer ID Number (for business entities).  Seemingly, the FCC has recognized that there has been much consternation among shareholders, officers and directors of broadcast companies about providing their Social Security Numbers to companies in which they have interests to in turn be provided to the FCC so that an FRN can be obtained.  So that licensees can have more time to deal with these issues, the provision for a temporary FRN has been adopted.  The FCC Public Notice also indicates that the FCC will host a workshop on December 9 at 2 PM Eastern time to help the public with issues as to the filing of this report.

The Social Security Number issue has perhaps created the most concern about this new form.  While the allowance for the temporary FRN will take some immediate pressure off broadcasters, these temporary numbers should not be viewed as a permanent reprieve from obtaining FRNs from all attributable owners.  The Commission in the revised Questions and Answers on the Form 323 makes clear, the temporary FRN for those holders of attributable interests in broadcast stations is a temporary measure.  Licensees are cautioned that they should use their best efforts to obtain these numbers (or to have the attributable owners, on their own, register for the FRN).  Even if that cannot be accomplished by the January 11 deadline, the licensee has an obligation to keep trying and to amend its filing when it finally obtains the required information as to the permanent FRN of each person or entity holding an attributable interest in the company .  The FCC seems to leave the door open to enforcement actions if a licensee does not obtain that information in a reasonable (though not defined) period of time.

While the Social Security Number ("SSN") issue has created a great deal of consternation to many shareholders, officers and directors, one broadcaster recently expressed to me his dismay at the concern.  After all, he pointed out, the SSN is a number assigned by the Federal government, and used for all sorts of government forms and applications (like when you file your tax return).  Here, the FCC - another Federal government agency - is asking for this information just like so many of its sister agencies.  As the SSN will not be made public by the FCC - it will only be used by the FCC internally to assign the FRN - the provision of this information should not be significantly different than filing this number with other government agencies, assuming that the FCC adopts security standards to keep this information confidential (a question about whether such standards have been adopted was raised by one law firm that has asked the Commission to delay the filing obligation).  With the reminder that attributable owners can themselves obtain the FRN and provide that to any licensee in which they have an interest (i.e. they do not need to provide their SSN number to the licensee), that should help to allay some fears.

It would also seem that most licensees will have Social Security Numbers for its shareholders and officers as if, for no other reason, that information is needed when paying dividends or salaries to these individuals.  We've noticed particular concerns about this issue in the case of nonprofit companies that hold commercial FCC licenses - perhaps as the Board members of these companies do not have a financial interest in the companies and did not anticipate the need to provide this sort of information to the companies in which they are involved.  While the current Form 323 obligation applies only to commercial stations, the Commission is considering extending the obligation to noncommercial licensees (see our post here).  The SSN issue may well be even more acute if and when these noncommercial licensees are brought within the scope of these new rules. 

In any event, it appears that the January 11 filing deadline for the new ownership report for commercial stations will hold - so be ready!