FCC Announces Date on Which Noncommercial FM Stations Can Ignore Analog Channel 6 TV Allotments

The FCC today announced that, effective October 27, noncommercial FM stations need no longer protect Channel 6 analog television channels.  The lower end of the FM band, which is reserved for noncommercial educational FM broadcasting, is immediately adjacent to TV Channel 6.  As most television stations abandoned Channel 6 in June when the digital television transition occurred, noncommercial stations had been protecting stations that were no longer there.  However, as we wrote here, the FCC wanted to deal with noncommercial licensees that were trying to jump the gun by filing applications contingent on the disappearance of the Channel 6 station even before the analog television stations had stopped operating.  To give all noncommercial FM stations an equal opportunity to take advantage of the clearing of Channel 6 in most television markets, the Commission set this uniform date for taking advantage of this change in television station operations.  Of course, noncommercial FM stations need to protect the handful of television stations that continue to operate digitally on Channel 6.  Today's public notice notes that noncommercial FM applications trying to take advantage of the fact that Channel 6 has been vacated in their market by filing an application before the October 27 date will be dismissed unless they had specific unconditional permission of the Channel 6 station.

Note that while the FCC has made the process equal for all noncommercial FM stations, there are questions about whether an unfair advantage may have been given to some LPTV stations in the recent LPTV filing window, where channel 6 applications were not prohibited (see our post here).  Some noncommercial broadcasters were concerned that some of these LPTV applicants could take advantage of the vacating of Channel 6 in their market by filing an application for a new LPTV station that could preclude the filing of an FM application once the window announced in this public notice opened.  To some extent, this may not be a major issue, as the LPTV window for applications for major markets does not open until January.  But we will see if this concern actually resulted in any issues in more rural areas as the LPTV applications that have already been filed in these areas are processed in coming months.  But for NCE FM stations that were precluded from filing for upgrades by a Channel 6 TV station that disappeared after the digital transition, the wait for filing opportunities will soon be over.

NCE Applications Must Protect Channel 6 TV Stations Until the End of the Digital Television Transition

Channel 6 of the television band is immediately adjacent to the lower end of the FM band.  Noncommercial FM radio stations, located at the lower end of the FM band (88.1 FM to 91.9), have the potential to interfere with television stations on that channel.  Thus, FCC rules require that noncommercial FM stations protect Channel 6 stations that are in their area, often limiting their power unless they can work out interference agreements with the local TV station.  As the FCC has tried to vacate Channel 6 as part of the digital transition, some noncommercial FM applicants, including some who filed during the recent filing window for new Noncommercial FM stations, have filed applications seeking construction permits at power levels that ignore the Channel 6 station, on the theory that, by the time the noncommercial station is on the air, the TV station will have vacated Channel 6.  In a decision issued on Friday, the Commission rejected one such application, finding that the acceptance of the application premised on an event that has not yet occurred would be unfair to potential applicants who were waiting to file applications until the television stations actually changed channels.

The decision, in a footnote, noted another problematic issue raised by these applications.  As only some applicants filed their applications in the recent NCE window premised on the disappearance of the Channel 6 TV stations, those that had not take that tact would be at a comparative disadvantage in assessing their applications under the NCE selection criteria.  As the comparative position of NCE applicants was supposed to have been frozen at the time the window applications were filed, those relying on a future event would seem to get an unfair advantage.  Thus, it appears that, in time, similar actions will be taken with respect to other similarly situated applicants, clearing up a source of concern or consternation for many who filed during that window.

Window for Filing New NCE Applications Extended Until 2 PM on October 22

The FCC today issued a Public Notice extending the NCE filing window, which was to end today, until this coming Monday, October 22.  All applications must be on file by 2 PM Eastern Time on Monday.  This short extension was apparently due to downtime on the FCC's electronic filing system last night, which precluded the filing of some applications during that period.  This is the window for filing applications seeking authority to construct new noncommercial educational FM stations, or for major changes in existing noncommercial FM stations.  For more details on this window, see our post, here