Comments Regarding Transition of Low Power Television Stations to Digital due December 17th

The Commission's recent Notice of Proposed Rule Making proposing a framework and time line for the transition of Low Power Television stations to digital operations -- which we wrote about last month here -- was published in the Federal Register today setting December 17, 2010 as the deadline for Comments and January 18, 2011 as the deadline for Reply Comments.  Interested parties should start preparing their comments now.  One continuing issue commenters should be aware of is the possibility of a television spectrum incentive auction or some other reclamation of television spectrum.  In seeking comment on the timing of the transition of LPTV stations to digital, the Commission has asked whether it makes sense for LPTVs to transition sooner rather than later and possibly face the need to reshuffle if the spectrum is compressed or otherwise reconfigured in the future, or alternatively, if LPTVs wait until the spectrum is settled before a DTV transition is mandated.  Comments on that issue and any others responsive to the Commission's NPRM are welcomed from all interested parties.  Comments can be filed in paper with the Commission or electronically through the ECFS filing system.  The proceeding has been designated as MB Docket No. 03-185.

FCC Suspends Indefinitely the Opportunity to Apply for New Digital Low Power Television Stations in Non-rural Areas

As we anticipated, the FCC has suspended indefinitely the opportunity to apply for new, digital low power television (LPTV) stations in non-rural areas, which had been slated to begin on July 26, 2010.  Given the FCC's new focus on repacking and reallocating the television spectrum for use by broadband competitors, the Commission's postponement of the filing opportunity is not unexpected.  In fact, based on the fact that the filing opportunity had been extended once already -- from January of this year to July -- it was a fairly safe bet that the window would be closed before it even opened once the National Broadband Plan was released in March.  It would seem to be counter-intuitive to put more stations into the spectrum that you are working to (potentially) reclaim or repack.  And that's just what the FCC thought as well, as they have now postponed "until further notice" filings for new digital LPTV stations in non-rural areas. 

Although it will not accept any applications for brand new digital LPTV stations in non-rural areas on July 26th, the Commission will permit existing LPTV, TV translator, and Class A television stations to file applications seeking digital companion channels in communities nationwide beginning on July 26, 2010.  In addition, parties may continue to file for new digital LPTV stations in rural areas, as well as file applications to flash-cut to digital on their current channels.  A copy of the FCC's Public Notice is available here

Pending Short-Form Applications for New Analog LPTVs Must Be Amended to Specify Digital Operations by May 24th

The FCC today issued a Public Notice  instructing applicants for new analog low power TV (LPTV) stations to amend their pending short-form applications by May 24th in order to specify digital operations. If the short-form application is not amended by May 24th it will be dismissed.  As some of you may recall, way back in 2000 the FCC opened a window for the filing of new LPTV stations. Rather than full applications, at the time applicants were simply required to file a "short form" tech-box application specifying the basic parameters of the proposal.  And of course, at the time the proposals were all for new analog LPTV facilities. Over the years, many of these proposals were found to be non-mutually exclusive, and the applicant applied for and received construction permits for new LPTV stations.  Other proposals were conflicted and were included in an FCC Auction to resolve the conflict, which also resulted in the grant of new construction permits. Many others, however, remained mutually exclusive and deadlocked. The FCC has now decided that, as it will no longer grant any new analog LPTV stations, any remaining proposals that are still pending must be amended to specify digital operations. 

Today's action is consistent with the Commission's pronouncement made last Summer when it announced the opportunity to commence filings for new LPTV stations in rural areas (which we wrote about here).  At that time, the FCC stated that going forward it would grant only digital LPTV stations and not any new analog LPTVs.  It's unclear why today's Public Notice was not released last year once that decision was made, but in any event today's action would appear to be one more step towards the ultimate transition of all LPTV stations to digital operations, which was mentioned as part of last week's National Broadband Plan (which we discussed here).  While the Commission has not yet set a date for the transition of existing analog LPTV stations to digital, the Broadband Plan suggested accelerating that process to migrate all broadcast television to digital operations.  However, the Plan also suggested potentially repacking the television spectrum, encouraging the consolidation of television operations, and changing interference protections for teleivsion stations, so whether the Commission would move forward with requiring analog LPTV stations to convert to DTV without clarifying some of these new proposals and their impact on low power television stations is unclear.  One other observation:  with the potential conversion to digital operations looming, the days of analog LPTV stations operating on TV Channel 6 and broadcasting audio intended to be received by FM radios would appear to be numbered. 

Returning to today's Public Notice, because full applications have not previously been filed for the pending proposals listed in the Notice, the FCC is requiring that applicants now amend the short-form applications by filing a complete long-form application.  The Commission is also requiring that applicants pay the $705 filing fee required for a major change.  (Just as an aside, the FCC filing fee required for new LPTV stations or major changes to existing stations at the time these proposals were filed in 2000 was $570.) 

The good news is that given the time, cost, and hassle involved in preparing and filing a full application to specify digital and the $705 filing fee it is likely that many of the proposals listed in this Public Notice will not be pursued, meaning that they will be dismissed, potentially breaking the log-jam that has prevented these proposals from being granted thus far.  But there is no guarantee that the remaining proposals will become grantable as a result.  It is very possible that an application will continue to be mutually exclusive to other proposals, in which case an auction would still be required to resolve the conflict.  But if parties are at all interested in preserving the opportunity to get a new LPTV on these channels in these places, they will need to amend and pay the fee by May 24th to keep the application alive. 

FCC Sets June 30th as "Cut-off Date" for Certain Class A, LPTV, and Translator Applications

This week ,the FCC issued a Public Notice addressing the issue of LPTV stations eager to displace to a new channel or switch to digital operations following the transition of full powers to DTV. (Please note, this notice does not address the filing of applications for brand new LPTV stations, which are still frozen). Many LPTV stations are eager to take advantage of the channels being returned by full power stations either to move their operations to those channels or to flash-cut to digital on their own channel now that an adjacent full-power station is gone.

In fact, some LPTV stations have already submitted applications seeking to move to a channel that is still occupied by a full power station, and which won't vacate the channel until June 12th. Because such applications did not comply with the then-current (pre-transition) interference landscape, they were not grantable at the time of filing, but will become grantable after June 12th. Similarly, many folks have their eye on a particular channel, and once the full power station terminates, the LPTVs will rush to move to that (now) vacant channel. The FCC's Public Notice states that for purposes of determining who filed first, the FCC will treat all such applications as though they were all filed on June 30th. Thus, there was no advantage to the LPTV station that filed for a channel last month that's still occupied by a full power, and there's no rush to be the first one to file for a newly vacated channel come 12:01 AM on June 13th.

What this means, however, is that if any LPTV station intends to take advantage of the full power DTV transition to displace to a newly vacated channel or to flash-cut to digital in a way that would be precluded because of pre-transition interference, any application filed between now and June 30th will be considered as filed the same day as any pending non-compliant application or application filed between now and the 30th that has a conflicting proposal.

This Public Notice does not appear to impact applications proposing changes that comply with the pre-transition interference landscape, which still can be filed at any time and should be processed on a first-come, first-served basis.

Class A LPTV Filing Freeze to Lift on August 4th

Yesterday, the FCC released its further Public Notice announcing that the freeze on filing certain Class A LPTV applications will be lifted on August 4th.  Previously, Class A stations had been frozen from expanding their authorized contours and from changing channels (displacing) while the DTV transition was underway.  Because Class A stations receive protection as primary stations, the FCC needed to lock those stations down until it had completed the DTV Table of Allotments, which it has now done.

Accordingly, as of August 4th (nearly four years to the day that the freeze was first imposed), Class A LPTV stations will once again be able to seek to modify their contours and change channels.  Applications filed prior to August 4th that requested a waiver of the freeze will be treated as having been filed on the 4th.  Thereafter, changes will be on a first come, first serve basis.  A copy of the public notice is available here